Some critics contend that there is
nothing especially unique about Fuller’s recipe for success. Instead,
they say he has simply capitalized on the phenomenon of disposable pop.
What they fail to realize however, is that despite all outward
appearances, Fuller has time and again reinvented himself.
The bands he promotes might all seem similar; the TV shows he produces all along the same lines. Still, over the past 25 years, Fuller has resisted producing stale content by continually adapting and updating it with the times.
Take, for instance, his successful music-reality TV franchise. From
Popstars to Pop Idol to So You Think You Can Dance, the market is
saturated. Does that mean Fuller’s time is up?
He does not think so. Indeed, he is the first to admit that, “In
England, the bubble’s already about to burst.” All that means however,
is that it is time for a change. “You’ve got to get in there while it’s
hot and get out before it’s cold…The clever thing is to take it and
parody it.”
That is exactly what Fuller proposed to do when he began discussing the
idea of a telethon with Fox TV executives. Fuller wanted to give one
week of his successful prime-time show over to a fundraising telethon.
Fox did not want anything to do with it. After all, who ever watches
telethons?
But Fuller pressed ahead with his idea. Instead of holding the
competition as usual, American Idol contestants were going to be
singing emotional songs while clips of the judges visiting troubled
Africa and Louisiana played. For every vote that was cast, sponsors
were to throw in some money for the causes. Throughout the following
week, performances by the likes of Pink and Borat were meant to
encourage donations from viewers themselves.
It was a risky move
for Fuller. Would viewers appreciate being asked for money on top of
votes? Would they appreciate having their regular show taken away from
them?
“I thought, actually, I control the biggest show in America,” said
Fuller. “And we have 30 million-plus people watching every week. Maybe
I could just hand over Idol for one week, and that would give us what
we want.”
Fuller did not want to turn Idol into a permanent fundraising telethon.
But he did have something else in mind besides just raising money for a
good cause. He was playing around with the idea of launching a whole
new TV genre, using this as his launching point.
“These things can be fantastically innovative and dynamic and not just
ploddy old telethons,” he says. “But, hats off to [Fox], they’re
supporting us. How reluctantly, I don’t know.”
Reinventing himself was a risky move
for Fuller. But time and again, he proves the benefits are worth the
risk. Next up, watch for Second Chance Idol on a TV set near you. “It’s
where we go to see people who have had a taste of fame, but sadly their candle has been snuffed.”